In 2009, I was visiting Barguna and Patuakhali in southern Bangladesh where, in 2007, cyclone Sidr had wreaked devastation. But I also saw cyclone shelters full of schoolchildren and volunteers roaming around, carrying megaphones.
An old woman told me, “When Bhola came, I lost many family members – now, water took my fishing pond, but my family was safe”. The damage to crops, livestock and the breach of embankments was huge. Yet lives were saved.
In 1970, Cyclone Bhola killed more than 300,000 people. In 2007, the similarly intense Cyclone Sidr killed less than 4000. In 2020, Cyclone Amphan killed a few hundred and over two million people were evacuated to shelters.
How did this happen? Bangladesh prepared and built resilience. For over fifty years, it invested in close to 6000 km of coastal embankments – earthen walls along the coast with sluice gates. They are not permanent. But they protect paddy from storm surges and tides. The country has also built over 4000 dual-use cyclone shelters. Many shelters operate as a school for 300 days a year. When a cyclone comes, hundreds of people can be evacuated to one shelter with their livestock safely secured on the first-floor ramp.
Bangladesh built a multi-layered early warning system that relies on weather monitoring technology, a communication system and community volunteers. The Met department can now track a cyclone five days early. What happens after tracking is what matters. Bangladesh uses its most important resource: the community. Over 75,000 volunteers – half of whom are women – under the Cyclone Preparedness Program, with megaphones, bicycles and flags, go door to door.
Bangladesh made disaster preparedness an express national priority with Standing Orders on Disasters, a dedicated Permanent Ministry of Disaster Relief and Management, and a protected Climate Change Trust Fund. Governments changed, but the priority for resilience did not. The country remains highly vulnerable and suffers from frequent natural disasters. Over 30 per cent of its cultivable land is in coastal areas threatened by rising sea levels and salinity. But it has successfully saved lives and reduced post-disaster losses.
Now, contrast with Pakistan in 2022. The floods were the worst in recorded history, submerging one-third of the country. The Post-Disaster Needs Assessment estimated total damages at over $14.9 billion and economic losses at about $15.2 billion. Over 1.1 million livestock died – the most precious asset of a village community. Over two million houses were damaged or destroyed and 13000 km of roads were damaged or washed out. Granted, it was a one-in-a-100-year flood. But could the damages have been less and losses reduced?
No shelters or raised platforms for livestock were ever built. Livestock did not die from rain. They died standing in water for 60 days without fodder. Forecasts and warnings existed, but they did not reach the rural level. Drainage networks in Sindh were heavily silted and were easily breached. Floodwater that should have drained to the sea in a few weeks was trapped for months, giving rise to waterborne diseases. Natural riverbeds were violated through unchecked construction of homes, hotels and roads in places like Kalam and Bahrain in Swat.
In 2022, our government lifted its head from a deep slumber. It made efforts to move from a reactive response to a technology-driven preparedness. Actions included: establishing the National Emergencies Operations Centre in Islamabad for 24/7 response; updating the National Flood Protection Plan; developing a framework for long-term recovery; training officials; and establishing evacuation protocols. Recently, a $500 million loan has been secured from ADB for emergency response.
These are good steps, yet the 2025 floods showed that implementation and enforcement remain slow. Families who did not receive warnings on time died near rivers. Agricultural losses could have been reduced with early harvesting and better drainage. Hundreds of roads, bridges, and thousands of houses were destroyed – many in the same places as in 2022, suffering ‘repeat damage’.
What lessons can we learn from Bangladesh? First, make preparedness an express national priority. Create a non-lapsable national fund whose money cannot be diverted when governments change. Use it for priority needs, such as shelters, in most high-risk areas. Earmark funds for maintenance of drains and embankments. Federal allocations can be paired with provincial budgetary allocations to sustain resilience building.
Second, set up a public monitoring system with a public dashboard. Before every monsoon, show which drains are cleaned, which embankments are repaired and how many shelters are prepared. Use drones to monitor any encroachments on the riverbeds.
Third, fix coordination issues. We need a legally binding federal-provincial-district protocol – with clear lines of accountability. Inter-provincial coordination mechanisms must also be made more effective and functional.
Fourth, technology-driven preparedness needs to be backed by community volunteers – including women. As Bangladesh shows, it is only a network of community volunteers that can reach as many people as possible. Institute mandatory flood drills, engaging community volunteers, well before the monsoons in the most flood-prone districts.
I left Bangladesh in 2012 thinking this is what preparedness looks like. I came back to Pakistan in 2022 and saw what happens when we don’t prepare. Floods will come; extreme climatic events will become more frequent and more severe. We cannot stop that, but preparedness can save lives and reduce damage and loss.
The next flood will come. Will we have built shelters, or will we be counting the dead?
The writer is a former director at the World Bank. She has served in the Caribbean, Nepal and Bangladesh.