Pakistan today is a nation without a compass – a failed education system, mass migration of talent abroad due to lack of jobs, collapsing industries, mega corruption and gross incompetence of the ruling elite.
Pakistan’s failure is not a failure of its people. It is a failure of direction, and the distance it has fallen can be measured. In 1978, China was poorer per head than Pakistan. Within four decades, it lifted some 800 million people out of poverty, became the world’s largest exporter, and took the lead in electric vehicles, solar power and high-speed rail. Pakistan, over the same years, went to the IMF more than twenty times and has been doomed by IMF policies to sink into a mountain of debt.
Consider Singapore. It has no farmland, no oil and no minerals, and only 6.1 million people on an island a fraction of the size of Karachi. Yet in 2025 it exported goods worth about $566 billion. Pakistan, with 252 million people, exported about $30.6 billion. Even allowing for the trade that merely passes through Singapore’s port, the gap is staggering: roughly $93,000 in exports for every Singaporean citizen against about $120 for every Pakistani.
As a result of corrupt and incompetent leadership, public spending on education fell to 0.8 per cent of GDP in FY2024-25, down from 1.9 per cent in 2019-20, against an international benchmark of 4-6 per cent. Some 26 million children are out of school. National spending on research and development has slipped to about 0.16 per cent of GDP, from 0.22 per cent a decade ago. Transparency International’s 2025 index gives Pakistan 28 points out of 100 and ranks it 136th of 182 nations. And the young are voting with their feet: more than 762,000 workers registered for employment abroad in 2025, after 727,000 the year before, and nearly 2.9 million have gone since 2022.
How did a country of such talent arrive here? The first reason is that it never chose a direction. Every nation that escaped poverty in the last half-century first answered a simple question: what will we be good at, and how will we get there? South Korea chose electronics and ships. China chose manufacturing, then science. Pakistan never answered. Meanwhile, the basis of wealth shifted. It now flows from knowledge: semiconductors, software, biotechnology, artificial intelligence, advanced materials. Land and cheap labour count for little.
The second reason is that Pakistan starved the mind. No country has become rich with an uneducated population, yet Pakistan behaves as if it could be the first. Children who do reach school too often sit in buildings without water or teachers, memorising notes for examinations that reward recall over thought. The colleges and universities above them are starved in turn: higher-education budgets have been largely frozen while the rupee lost its value, and faculties are losing their best researchers. Nor is there any innovation policy to connect what little research is done to the economy. No ministry is held answerable for high-technology exports. Private industry contributes less than a tenth of the nation’s meagre research spending.
The third reason follows from the first two: an economy that makes nothing sophisticated creates no jobs for the educated. Nearly two-thirds of Pakistanis are under-30. This should be the greatest asset any nation could ask for. Instead, it has become a queue at the passport office.
The fourth reason is corruption, which in Pakistan is not petty leakage but a system. Contracts are inflated, loans are written off, public land is gifted and the proceeds are parked abroad. Accountability arrives only as a weapon against whoever is out of power.
Behind all of these stands the deepest reason: poor political leadership, produced by a system that can produce nothing better. Our parliamentary system fills the cabinet from the assemblies, and the assemblies from the ranks of landlords, dynasts and electables who know how to win a constituency but not how to run energy, finance or science. Beneath them, secretaries are generalists shuffled between ministries every few months.
What, then, must change? China shows that even a vast and poor nation can be transformed within a generation, and it shows how. It chose a direction and held it. It poured money into schools, universities and laboratories, sent its brightest abroad and drew them home with funding and respect. Above all, it placed engineers and scientists in charge and promoted officials on results.
The goal must be a technology-driven knowledge economy. That means schools that teach children to think, technical colleges that supply skilled workers and universities judged by the research and the companies they generate. It means industries that move up from cloth to engineering goods, pharmaceuticals, software and electronics. And it means bringing home the talent that has left, and giving the young a reason to stay.
That begins with governance. A genuine presidential democracy would have a directly elected president free to appoint the nation’s finest experts as ministers, with secretaries who are specialists in their fields beneath them, a parliament confined to lawmaking and oversight and empowered local governments below.
The rest of the agenda is not mysterious. Declare a national emergency in education and raise spending to at least four per cent of GDP. Lift research funding tenfold and tie it to industry. Adopt a national innovation policy that rewards firms for exporting technology. Devolve money and authority to elected local councils. Make accountability blind to party.
The writer is a former federal minister, Unesco science laureate and founding chairperson of the Higher Education Commission (HEC). He can be reached at: [email protected]