The debate over creating new provinces – essentially another version of devolution of power plus – has returned to Pakistan’s political agenda.
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has described the governance system as having failed and proposed seeking public opinion on new administrative units. Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has called for discussion of administrative reform, while also stressing the need to strengthen local governments. The government has said it is not drafting a constitutional amendment to create provinces; some within the government claim total ignorance of any discussion, while the defence minister says it’s nearly a done deal.
Some context is necessary: this is not a new debate. It is part of a longer struggle over where power should reside: with the federation, provincial governments or elected representatives closer to citizens. New provinces may make government more accessible and manageable. But changing the map alone will not repair a system in which authority, resources and accountability remain concentrated at the top. The real test is whether decisions can be made near the people affected by them, with clear responsibility for results.
Pakistan’s experience with local government and power devolution requires some caution. Successive civilian governments have often been reluctant to transfer meaningful political, administrative and financial authority to elected local representatives. Military governments have promoted local government systems, including Gen Pervez Musharraf’s 2001 devolution plan, but such arrangements, even when reasonable, have also been criticised for serving the political interests of the regime that introduced them. When Musharraf left office, the system was dismantled and responsibility returned to the provinces.
The pattern reflects a persistent problem: governments may endorse devolution in principle while resisting it in practice. Provincial governments can reproduce at their own level the centralising habits they repeatedly oppose at the federal level. The result is that local communities remain distant from decisions about services, development and public spending. Exasperated citizens, disconnected from the blood and flesh of decision-making structures, are rendered powerless when services fail.
The 18th Amendment, passed in 2010, was a landmark transfer of authority from the federation to the provinces. It also required each province to establish local government and devolve political, administrative and financial responsibility to elected local representatives. Sixteen years later, the gap between that constitutional promise and citizens’ everyday experience remains a central question of governance. The debate on new provinces should confront that gap directly. Provincial autonomy did not itself guarantee devolution within provinces; creating another tier without clear powers may only add complexity.
Pakistan’s history shows the consequences of treating the distribution of power as a contest among the ruling elites rather than as a means to serve citizens. Our governance challenge has been continuously subsumed in the abiding contestation between the khaki’s muscle power and the mufti’s weakening political power. The creation of One Unit, the later restoration of provinces, the separation of East Pakistan, and recurring power-play and political confrontations all belong to a chaotic national journey. They should not be reduced to a single explanation. But they underline why constitutional arrangements must be built around representation, fairness and public confidence, not personalised advantage. Where communities feel excluded, boundaries become tied to identity, dignity and access to resources.
The argument for new provinces has merit. Large populations and vast territories can make administration remote and slow. Smaller units may improve access to public services, make officials more answerable and allow regions to develop their economic and human potential. Yet these are possibilities, not automatic outcomes. A new province that simply moves the centre of power from one city to another, without sharing authority with its districts and towns, would reproduce the same problem on a smaller scale. The case for each unit should be tested against evidence on population, geography and service delivery.
Six principles should guide the debate and decisions: First, define the purpose. New provinces must be designed to improve governance: better public services, more responsive administration, fairer representation and stronger accountability. The case should rest on evidence about population, distance, service delivery and regional needs. Administrative convenience cannot be the only measure; nor should the process become a device for settling political scores. The intended gains should be measurable.
Second, agree on the powers each province will have. A province needs the institutions and resources to carry out its responsibilities. Its administrative structure, revenue arrangements, law-enforcement responsibilities and relationship with local governments must be clearly set out. Police arrangements and access to justice require particular attention: the objective should be effective, accountable services, with safeguards for independence and citizens’ rights. If authority continues to be controlled from the centre, whether federal or provincial, the new unit will offer little genuine devolution.
Third, publish a detailed blueprint before asking the public to decide. Citizens should know how boundaries, staffing, assets, debts, public services and finances would be handled. They should see the proposed arrangements for administration, law enforcement, commerce and development. Without this information, consultation or a referendum risks asking people to endorse a label rather than a workable governing structure.
Fourth, build political and public acceptance through the constitutional process. The issue has become entangled with party competition and bargaining over power. Those dynamics cannot simply be wished away, but they should not determine the outcome. Article 239 requires a constitutional amendment passed by two-thirds of each house of parliament; if it alters provincial limits, the affected provincial assembly must also approve it by a two-thirds majority. Article 48 provides for a referendum on a matter of national importance only after approval at a joint sitting of parliament. A referendum may help establish public opinion, but it cannot substitute for the constitutional requirements.
Fifth, settle resource-sharing fairly and transparently. Revenue, natural resources, mining rights, infrastructure and public assets must be addressed before boundaries are finalised. Article 172(3) says mineral oil and natural gas within a province are jointly and equally vested in that province and the federation. New arrangements must respect the constitution while providing a credible system for sharing revenues and benefits among the federation, provinces and affected communities. Ports and other federal responsibilities also require clear rules. No region should be left feeling that it has surrendered control without receiving a fair share.
Sixth, design units that can govern efficiently. Creating provinces should not mean multiplying offices and administrative overhead. Careful planning can reduce duplication and bring decisions closer to citizens, but lower costs are not guaranteed by redrawing boundaries.
Pakistan’s present political order makes this debate especially sensitive. Competing parties have different interests, and the balance of influence among elected and unelected institutions shapes what can be proposed and negotiated. Recognising that political reality is not a reason to abandon reform. It is a reason to make the process more open, legally sound and difficult to manipulate. A proposal with administrative, political and development merit needs public consent.
The demand for closer, more effective government is real. But the test is not how many new provinces Pakistan creates, but whether a new constitutional and administrative architecture distributes authority fairly, protects the federation, strengthens local government and delivers visible results.