On October 9, 2026, Nepra notified the Use of System Charges for Pakistan's competitive electricity market. That notification merely fulfilled a regulatory requirement.
INDUSTRIAL TARIFFS
On October 9, 2026, Nepra notified the Use of System Charges for Pakistan's competitive electricity market. That notification merely fulfilled a regulatory requirement.
An industrial consumer in Pakistan can now buy electricity directly from a power producer of his choice, anywhere in the country. The first auction of 400 megawatts is open, with bids due by November 20. A second round of equal size will follow. It took years to get here, and the energy sector reform deserves recognition.
But a reform is only as good as the numbers written into it. A few features of the notified charges deserve closer examination, and maybe a well-considered revision in the larger interest of system efficiency, before the auction results are settled, because getting the pricing structure right at the start will determine whether competition actually delivers lower costs or simply rearranges the same burden.
Under the new system (CTBCM), large electricity consumers can buy power directly from private, competitive power generators rather than relying solely on distribution companies (DISCOs). To move that privately purchased electricity from the generator's plant to the buyer's factory, the buyer must use the existing national grid and local distribution infrastructure. Thus, the new system comes with multi-part Use of System charges.
Think of this as a toll for using the national grid on top of whatever energy price it pays to its supplier. Nepra has set wheeling charges at Rs6.23 per unit for a factory connected at 11 kilovolts and Rs9.09 for one connected at 132 kilovolts. A consumer who stays outside CTBCM faces higher charges, Rs19.17 and Rs25.45 respectively.
The cross-subsidy anomaly in Pakistan's industrial tariff structure is already well documented and contested. If one sets aside the cross-subsidy component in the notified charges, the 11 kV consumer pays about Rs3.6 per unit in network costs while the 132 kV consumer, who uses less infrastructure and loses just 1.5 per cent against 8.0 per cent, pays about Rs4. The cross-subsidy loading deepens the disparity: Rs5.05 per unit on the 132 kV consumer, nearly double the Rs2.63 levied on the 11 kV consumer. These numbers need to be addressed before the CTBCM auction settles, not explained away after it.
Export-oriented textile mills have long advocated removing cross-subsidies, where industrial tariffs are kept high to subsidise low-income domestic users under the pretext of cost to serve. By incorporating cross-subsidies ranging from Rs2.63 per unit for B-3 to Rs5.05 for B-4 and up to Rs15.58 for the C-2 category directly into the Use of System Charges, Nepra has ensured that textile mills cannot escape paying cross-subsidies even if they disconnect from standard utility tariffs and buy power from private sellers. The government's own Strategic Directive 84 envisaged cross-subsidy from productive consumers to be capped at 20 per cent of cost of service by the end of FY2026, a deadline that has already passed.
The fixed capacity charge should transition to volumetric charging per kilowatt-hour, because the current structure penalises factories during low-demand cycles, maintenance shutdowns or when using captive power
These are questions of calibration, not of principle. The competitive market is the right policy. But if the network charges carry anomalies that go unaddressed, the auction may produce outcomes shaped by pricing signals that do not reflect actual costs. That would be unfortunate for a reform designed to let price discovery do its work.
The timing adds urgency. Exporters have warned that textile shipments are likely to decline between October and December. Global buyers are pulling back, and sea freight has risen by up to 2.5 times. The Export Finance Scheme, announced at 4.5 per cent for this fiscal year, has not reached exporters at that rate, with banks charging 5.5 per cent at a minimum and some as high as 8.5 per cent. Similarly, the Duty Drawback, which the industry has asked to be restored at 6-8 per cent, remains pending.
This is not just a question of cost transparency. It is a structural problem inherent in the model. While the fixed charge is kept low, the high per-unit variable rates impose a substantial cost on energy-intensive textile processes. Nepra's move ensures that export-oriented industries cannot escape paying legacy grid inefficiencies, debt servicing, or cross-subsidies even if they switch entirely to third-party private generation through the grid. Inflated wheeling charges will further undermine competitiveness.
Regional competitors in Bangladesh and Vietnam pay energy tariffs of 6-8 cents per kilowatt-hour. With Pakistan's wheeling charges alone amounting to roughly 4.5 cents per unit, Pakistani textile exporters risk being priced out of international markets.
The October 9 gazette notification is a real achievement. It moves the competitive market from paper to law. The exit door from the old model has opened, and that is good. But the ladder needs its rungs checked before the first consumers climb it.
The Pakistan Textile Council has consistently called for removing cross-subsidies, debt servicing surcharges and stranded costs from open-access transactions, with a clear, time-bound phase-out schedule. Likewise, DISCOs should offset revenue gaps by improving their own efficiency rather than penalising exporters.
Lastly, the fixed capacity charge should transition to volumetric charging per kilowatt-hour, because the current structure penalises factories during low-demand cycles, maintenance shutdowns or when using captive power. A few structural corrections now will save far larger distortions later.
Aqsa Gull is a senior research associate and Moaaz Manzoor is a research associate at the Pakistan Textile Council.
The views expressed are their own and do not necessarily represent those of the Council.