close
Money Matters

Why intermodal connectivity matters

By  Engr Abdul Hanan Aftab
02 November, 2026

Thousands of trucks transport goods from Karachi ports to Lahore, Islamabad, and Peshawar every day. They clog the roads, burn expensive fuel and damage them.

RAILWAYS

Why intermodal connectivity matters

Thousands of trucks transport goods from Karachi ports to Lahore, Islamabad, and Peshawar every day. They clog the roads, burn expensive fuel and damage them.

Meanwhile, the railway is largely unused, even though it can transport the same goods at a lower cost. This is the problem of weak intermodal connectivity. Intermodal refers to using two or more modes of transportation seamlessly, such as ship, train and truck. These modes are used independently in Pakistan. They are not connected in a single chain.

Roads are over-reliant in Pakistan. A 2025 policy brief by the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry (FPCCI) says over 94 per cent of cargo moves by road and only about 6.0 per cent by rail. After independence, railways carried about 75 per cent of freight. In contrast, India still carries 20 per cent of freight by rail.

The railway has become weak. The number of working locomotives fell from 528 in 2011 to 449 in 2025. Poor connectivity of ports to the interior is also a problem. Gwadar was built with high expectations, but it serves less than 0.5 per cent of the country's trade because of poor road and supply-chain conditions. There is no central authority either. Different ministries control roads and railways, and no one is responsible for a container's entire journey from ship to shop.

Logistics expenses in Pakistan are approximately 15.6 per cent of GDP. It is just 8-9 per cent in the US, Japan and Singapore. According to the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), transport sector inefficiency costs the economy between Rs4.6 trillion and Rs6.9 trillion annually. Heavy trucks also cause damage to roads and bridges. The World Bank attributes this to an annual loss of about 2.0 per cent of GDP. The World Bank's Logistics Performance Index for Pakistan decreased from 2.42 in 2018 to 2.3.

Rail is also better for fuel. One estimate says a gallon of fuel can transport a ton of goods 250 miles by rail and 90 miles by road. Farmers also pay a price. Poor storage and weak cold chains result in the loss of about 30-40 per cent of fruits and vegetables after harvest.

The government already knows this. The National Transport Policy states that freight should be moved from road to rail and pipelines. It also calls for improved connectivity of ports, dry ports and industrial zones. It suggests a cabinet committee, headed by the prime minister, to guide all modes. The National Freight and Logistics Policy of 2021 is in the same direction.

There is some improvement. DP World, Pakistan Railways and the National Logistics Corporation started work on a freight corridor and logistics park at Pipri in Karachi in January 2026. The first phase involves reconstructing about 52 kilometres of the rail line from Karachi Port to Pipri, enabling container transport by rail rather than road.

Rail freight must be operated as a business. Pakistan Railways should establish a separate freight department

The main railway line (ML-1) is 1726 kilometres long from Karachi to Peshawar. The plan would increase the number of train pairs from 34 to 120 and raise freight train speeds from 30-80 kilometres per hour. The Asian Development Bank is funding a large portion of the Karachi-Rohri section, estimated to cost about $2.5 billion. Officials had hoped to begin work in September, but that date has been delayed before.

Railways collected Rs115 billion in 2025-26, up 20 per cent, and has targeted freight revenue of Rs65 billion this year. The minister says this requires more than 40 additional working locomotives. ML-2 will be built as a public-private partnership, while ML-3 will facilitate trade with Iran. The actual difference is between announcement and delivery. Dates change, budgets shrink and freight still comes second to passenger trains.

India has built Dedicated Freight Corridors (DFCs) exclusively for goods trains. Goods trains are no longer waiting behind passenger trains, and they are now faster and carry more. China links its big ports directly to rail lines and inland container hubs, so a container can move from ship to train with little waiting.

The Port of Rotterdam in the Netherlands is Europe's hub for ships, trains, and river barges. The European Union has targeted 30 per cent of road freight over 300 kilometres to be transported by rail or water by 2030. The common lessons are clear. These countries have their own freight tracks, direct rail connections to ports, private companies that can operate trains and own wagons, and digital systems for booking and tracking freight.

Pakistan needs one clear authority to lead this change. A National Logistics Authority, under the cabinet committee on transport, should coordinate planning for roads, rail, ports and air cargo. It should establish goals and report annually on what is working, so that everyone can see.

Rail freight must be operated as a business. Pakistan Railways should establish a separate freight department. Private companies should be permitted to own wagons and containers and operate their own trains on the tracks for a fee. Rail prices should remain competitive with road prices, giving traders a good reason to switch. The final mile also needs to be addressed. Ports, dry ports and special economic zones should connect to the railway through rail sidings. Gwadar also needs proper links to the rest of the country, so it can serve national trade.

Work should not stop and start with ML-1; it should be funded consistently in all budgets. The government should implement public-private partnerships for ML-2, terminals and logistics parks, with well-defined contracts and risk-sharing arrangements. Pakistan also needs to go digital. A single freight booking and tracking platform, connected to the Pakistan Single Window, would let traders book port, rail and truck services from one place.

Everyone will stay on track with clear public targets. For instance, rail's share of freight may increase to 10 per cent in three years and 20 per cent in the future. Progress should be reported every year. Last but not least, the plan must address trucks and cold chains. Old trucks should be phased out and drivers should be trained. To reduce food losses, build cold storage close to farms and ports.

Intermodal connectivity is not about building more roads or more railways alone. It's about getting them to cooperate. Pakistan has the plans, the policies and some early projects. What it needs now is one clear owner, steady funding and honest tracking of results. Moving goods smartly reduces costs, saves our roads, supports exporters and saves fuel.


The writer is an MPhil Scholar at PIDE and can be reached at: [email protected] 

More From Money Matters
Cargoes are not a gas plan
By Saqib Ur Rehman Mughal

Cargoes are not a gas plan
By Nayyar Hussain Mirjat

Why intermodal connectivity matters
By Engr Abdul Hanan Aftab

The missing link
By Asif Javed

The real bull market
By Muhammad Farooq

Is Pakistan a mismanaged destination?
By Dr Shabbir Abbas Naqvi