close

Sindh’s geographical integrity non-negotiable, say six mayors

By Our Correspondent
November 21, 2026
Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab is seen along with other mayors of Sindh at the Karachi Press Club on November 20, 2026. — Facebook@Bilawalhouse/Screengrab
Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab is seen along with other mayors of Sindh at the Karachi Press Club on November 20, 2026. — Facebook@Bilawalhouse/Screengrab

KARACHI: Mayors of six divisional headquarters across Sindh on Friday strongly rejected Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQMP) Convener Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui’s recent remarks on the creation of new provinces and administrative units, declaring that Sindh’s geographical integrity was non-negotiable.

Addressing a joint press conference at the Karachi Press Club, Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab, Sukkur Mayor and Sindh government spokesperson Arsalan Islam Shaikh, Hyderabad Mayor Kashif Shoro, Larkana Mayor Anwar Luhar, Nawabshah Mayor Qazi Rasheed Bhatti and Mirpurkhas Mayor Abdul Rauf Ghori maintained that the creation of new provinces could only take place in accordance with Article 239(4) of the Constitution.

They said Article 140A had no connection with the formation of new provinces and that calls for a referendum on the matter amounted to a departure from the constitutional framework. The mayors also demanded an apology for “mocking Sindh’s culture and promoting ethnic politics”.

Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab said hatred was among the most damaging forces for any society, adding that the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) believed in bringing people together. He said the mayors representing all six divisional headquarters of Sindh had gathered to promote a message of love and harmony.

He said Sindh had a history spanning 5,000 years and Karachi’s history did not begin in 1947.

The shrine of Hazrat Abdullah Shah Ghazi, he pointed out, is also situated in Karachi.

Recalling the city’s past, Wahab said ethnic divisions had been encouraged during his formative years.

Karachi was once considered the jewel of the region in the 1970s, but the promotion of ethnic politics in the 1980s had divided communities and destroyed social harmony. He said homes had once symbolised love and peace, but an atmosphere of fear subsequently took hold.

Frequent shutter-down and wheel-jam strikes, extortion, kidnapping for ransom and terrorism became part of Karachi’s past. A city once renowned for education, literature and culture had witnessed the pen being replaced by the gun.

Wahab said his generation had not experienced the city’s better days and that peace had been restored only after immense sacrifices by political workers, journalists and law enforcement personnel. He said Karachi must never return to the conditions of the 1980s and 1990s.

Taking a swipe at the MQMP, he questioned its internal unity, saying Siddiqui’s press conference had not even been attended by Mustafa Kamal.

He remarked that a party divided by internal differences could hardly claim the authority to decide Sindh’s future, adding that the political dispute had now shifted from Nine Zero to Bahadurabad and Raees Amrohvi Road.

Wahab said the Constitution clearly stipulated how provincial boundaries could be altered. Under the 1973 Constitution, the procedure for creating new provinces was explicitly laid down. He termed Siddiqui’s argument legally untenable.

He stressed that the priority should be addressing people’s economic difficulties, rather than diverting attention towards divisive political debates. Referring to PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s position, he said public issues deserved greater attention.

Wahab said the people of Sindh wanted to remain united and described himself as an Urdu-speaking Sindhi. Pakistan, he added, had been created through the collective struggle of the country’s forefathers, and hatred and prejudice would achieve nothing.

He warned against applying different standards to Sindh and Punjab, saying that disregarding the Constitution today could open the door to similar demands elsewhere.

He urged political leaders to follow constitutional principles and resolve disputes through dialogue rather than inflaming tensions. “Problems are solved by extinguishing fires, not by setting them alight,” he said, calling for attempts to create divisions to be stopped before they escalated.

Sukkur Mayor Arsalan Islam Shaikh said the joint press conference was a response to Siddiqui’s recent remarks, which he described as contrary to facts.

He questioned the basis of the MQMP leader’s claims, arguing that the mayors had been elected through public votes and therefore represented the people’s mandate.

He said adding the word ‘United’ (Muttahida) to a party’s name did not necessarily make it united, referring to recent internal disagreements and clashes within the MQMP.

He also criticised the party for avoiding electoral contests in the past when it anticipated poor results, adding that Siddiqui’s 40-minute press conference had failed to address the country’s economic challenges. Shaikh accused the MQM of having presided over a period of violence in Sindh.

He said Sindh was the province of Quaid-i-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah and had extended exceptional hospitality following the creation of Pakistan in 1947. Describing Sindh as a land of 5,000-year-old civilisation and Sufi saints, he demanded an apology and the withdrawal of remarks comparing Sindhi culture to the jungles of Africa.

He urged the MQMP leadership not to provoke the people of Sindh or ridicule their cultural identity.

Shaikh said no one had the authority to prevent Sindh’s elected representatives from defending the province’s integrity. Reiterating that all mayors stood against Sindh’s division, he warned that if the current approach continued, their next press conference could be held at Nine Zero alongside residents of Karachi’s urban constituencies. “Karachi is not anyone’s personal property,” he said.

Defending the PPP’s performance, he said the party had restored peace in Karachi and that the city no longer faced the conditions that had prevailed in the past. He said previous mayors had repeatedly complained about a lack of authority, whereas the incumbent mayor had access to a district Annual Development Programme (ADP) budget worth billions of rupees. He praised Murtaza Wahab for working continuously towards the city’s development.

Shaikh clarified that the PPP was not opposed to the creation of new provinces where constitutional requirements were fulfilled and public grievances remained unaddressed. However, he said the same standards must apply to both Punjab and Sindh. He pointed out that Punjab could pursue the creation of new provinces through its provincial assembly, while Sindh had maintained its local government system under the PPP for the past decade.

Responding to Siddiqui’s reference to Article 140A and a Supreme Court judgment, Shaikh said the constitutional provision concerned the empowerment of local government institutions and had nothing to do with the creation of new provinces. He accused the MQMP leader of deliberately misinterpreting the constitution and said a petition under Article 199 would be filed against him over what he described as a distortion of constitutional provisions.

Referring to Article 48(6), Shaikh said a referendum was a means of obtaining public opinion on a particular matter, but the constitution already prescribed a specific procedure for creating new provinces under Article 239(4). He questioned the need for a referendum when a constitutional mechanism was already in place, arguing that such a proposal could only be considered where no established legal procedure existed or new legislation was required.

He further said that attempts to create an atmosphere of ethnic confrontation or seize urban constituencies in Sindh on linguistic grounds would not succeed in the presence of Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.

Shaikh recalled that former prime minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto had accepted the gallows in the struggle to preserve democracy and prevent bloodshed, while former prime minister Benazir Bhutto had also sacrificed her life. He said that in 2007, Asif Ali Zardari had raised the slogan ‘Pakistan Khappay’ to save the country from further bloodshed. Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, he added, was carrying forward the democratic legacy of his leadership.

He had argued that administrative units should be considered in provinces where effective local government systems did not exist. He said Bilawal Bhutto Zardari’s call for resetting the system was made in the context of consultations with all stakeholders.

He maintained that any proposed restructuring should involve all political parties, including the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) and MQMP, as well as the judiciary and legal fraternity.

He noted that the 1973 Constitution and the 18th Constitutional Amendment had emerged through consensus among stakeholders, while some stakeholders had not been included in consultations on the 27th Constitutional Amendment.

Shaikh also alleged irregularities in the previous census, claiming that around Rs40 billion had been spent on the exercise and that Karachi’s urban population figures, which had initially been recorded at a higher level, were subsequently deleted following objections raised by the MQM.

Hyderabad Mayor Kashif Shoro said the seeds of hatred sown by the MQM among the public had continued to influence society for decades. However, he maintained that people had become aware of the party’s politics and that the hopes with which voters had elected MQM’s representatives had now faded.

He said the public was educated and politically aware, and would no longer tolerate further damage caused by ethnic and divisive politics.

Shoro added that people in Hyderabad lived together peacefully and questioned whether the MQM wanted to revive the troubled past. He urged the MQM to demonstrate its performance instead of promoting confrontation, pointing out that it had been part of governments at different times.

Larkana Mayor Anwar Luhar said Siddiqui had made remarks about Larkana despite the MQM not having even a single councillor in the city. He said PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari spoke not only for Sindh but for the entire country. The MQMP leader’s statements, he added, were creating disappointment among the people of Karachi and Sindh and risked creating an impression that could strengthen anti-Pakistan elements.

Luhar said the presence of the mayors at the press conference was also intended to demonstrate symbolically that elected representatives from Sindh’s urban areas stood with the PPP. He emphasised that all of them had secured their positions through the people’s votes.

Mirpurkhas Mayor Abdul Rauf Ghori said the people of Mirpurkhas had rejected the MQM in elections. He said Asif Ali Zardari had responded by raising the slogan ‘Pakistan Khappay’ to promote national unity. He added that the MQM would struggle to find a candidate in Mirpurkhas in the next election.