Perishing in public interest

November 1, 2026

Threats and intimidation have never been strangers to journalism

Perishing in public interest


L

ast week, The Black Hole, a modest auditorium in Islamabad overflowed with eager listeners. The hall, launched in early 2022 to be a venue for open and honest debate, featured a candid conversation about veteran journalist Mazhar Abbas’s latest book, Media Under the Shadow of Death. Many who couldn’t make it inside, waited around, smoked cigarettes and gossiped that the organisers must be both happy and worried about the ‘success’ of the event—happy because serious debate seldom attracts organic listeners in large numbers these days; and worried because the popularity of critical or controversial debates can attract intelligence sleuths.

Mazhar’s book examines Pakistan’s struggle for Press freedoms: the scourge of sustained administrative pressure, state censorship and societal violence. Imagine the pain, perplexity and perseverance of those who participated in the freedom struggle for an independent country and then had to face the colonial legacy of draconian administrative suppression and societal servility.

Around fifteen years ago, British journalist and author (now a professor) Anatol Lieven described Pakistan as a “divided, disorganised, economically backward, corrupt, violent, unjust, often savagely oppressive towards the poor and women, and home to extremely dangerous forms of extremism and terrorism,” in his book, Pakistan: A Hard Country.

Journalists are often described as watchdogs of public interest. International research has shown that people in power behave more responsibly when an independent media performs its watchdog role: keeping an eye on the people in power and pointing out illegality, misuse of power and corruption etc.

In Pakistan, however, the state and society have routinely opted for intentional and depressive bipolarity about Press freedoms because the state has regularly been accused of preferring dictatorship to democracy. Meanwhile, the society has failed to shed its medieval era intolerance.

Perishing in public interest

The Pakistani state was quickly taken over by the middle-level civil and military bureaucrats who chose to run the country using British-era colonial security laws to counter perceived dissent. The new state faced many problems. Given their lack of experience, the leadership struggled. A free Press was seen as an unnecessary distraction. Hence the urge to purge the unchained watchdogs.

The sad story that started with the deployment of the Public Safety Ordinance (1948), the Pakistani Security Act (1952) and Official Secrets Act to shutter independent newspapers and incarcerate uncooperative editors in the 1950s, metamorphosed into systematic control under Ayub Khan’s martial law administration in the 1960s. The promulgation of the Press and Publication Order; the creation of the National Press Trust; the introduction of the Press advice (wherein state officials would instruct newsrooms what to print or omit, going as far in some cases as to specify how to frame headlines) illustrate the mindset.

Things didn’t improve when elected governments arrived in the 1970s. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto’s nationalisation policy brutalised the advertising pie that had fed the independent Press. The government then became the single largest buyer of advertising space. Independent media was punished and servile outlets were rewarded. Defiant editors were routinely jailed and stubborn publications faced regular crackdowns.

Perishing in public interest


53 journalists were killed between 2012 and 2022. Sadder still is the fact that formal convictions were achieved in only two cases, reflecting a shocking 96 percent impunity rate.

The darkest period for Pakistani media and journalists, however, was during Gen Zia-ul Haq’s repressive regime. Imprisoning editors, shuttering publication houses and implementing strictest censorship were known from the past. Gen Zia made the punishment of journalists a public spectacle. Journalists were publicly flogged for the first time in the country’s history. (Nasir Zaidi, Khawar Naeem Hashmi and Iqbal Jaffery were sentenced by military courts.)

Mahnaz Rahman, a veteran journalist and rights activist, wrote in her book, Love, Life and the Left that Gen Zia warned his martial law administrators: “Beware of the Left. Beware of a united front of journalists, workers and students.” Amendments to the penal code opened floodgates for public punitive action.

Following Gen Zia’s death in a 1988 plane crash, democratic governance revitalised the media. New newspapers cropped up all over the country. But the expansion of print media in the 1990s and the introduction of electronic media in early 2000s brought new dangers for independent and investigative journalists.

Journalists and media owners were familiar with state oppression but new threats and dangerous retaliation began emerging from militant groups, political parties and criminal- mafias.

As if threats of abduction, physical torture and grievous body harm were not enough, high-profile targeted murders were committed to scare media persons. Kidnapping and murder of Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl, targeted killing of Geo News correspondents Musa Khan Khel in Matta, Swat Valley, Wali Khan Babar in Karachi, and gunning down of Shan Dahar in Sindh shook many dedicated journalists working in conflict zones.

Perishing in public interest

By early 2020s, extremist violence had been reported from almost everywhere in Pakistan.

The assassination of Arshad Sharif in 2022 in Kenya and military court trials and sentences handed down in absentia against self-exiled media persons like Moeed Pirzada in 2026 represent an expansion of the threats.

Research by organisations like the Freedom Network has reveal that 53 journalists were killed between 2012 and 2022. Sadder still is the fact that formal convictions were achieved in only two cases, reflecting a shocking 96 percent impunity rate. Weak investigations, lukewarm interest in nabbing the culprits and flawed prosecution have forced many journalists to self-censor in order to survive.

Last November, Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif promised on the International Day to End Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists that his administration would take measures to ensure effective investigations and prosecutions for crimes against journalists. National and international media watchdogs and safety coalitions claim that between 140 and 170 journalists and media workers have been killed in Pakistan since 2000.

The trouble with government promises is they have rarely been fulfilled.

Families, friends, colleagues and comrades of the deceased media persons have never asked for extrajudicial action against killers and kidnappers of journalists. But they do resent the 96 percent impunity rate. The state and the society must remember that these people laid down their lives in public interest.


The writer is the resident editor of The News in Islamabad.

Perishing in public interest