Unlocking economic potential

A country’s future is defined by how effectively it converts its resources into investment, exports, productive employment and sustainable national wealth

Unlocking economic potential


E

conomic discourse in Pakistan is often dominated by scarcity: fiscal pressures, shortage of foreign exchange, low investment, high energy cost and persistent balance of payment issues. We have become so accustomed to handling these issues that we sometimes overlook the opportunities in front of us.

Pakistan is an economically challenged nation partly because it lacks the capacity to transform its economic opportunities into productive investment, exports, jobs and sustainable prosperity. The country is endowed with certain economic advantages such as mineral wealth, energy resources, youth, fertile land, tourism resources and strategic location. The point is to make the most out of these advantages. This demands a strategic rethink from resources management to value creation, from stability to productivity and from standalone ventures to economic ecosystem.

Turning minerals

into industry

Pakistan’s mineral wealth has recently received renewed attention. The minerals represent an opportunity for investments, jobs and exports. However, mere extraction and export cannot be the purpose of a mining focus. Real economic benefits come further along the value chain. Mining can create demand for processing and refining, transport, engineering services, equipment, energy and specialised skills. Once mining triggers off these industries, the benefits can spread well beyond the mine.

Pakistan should adopt a mining to manufacturing approach. The mineral economic zones can include mining operation, processing plants, logistics firms, engineering companies, universities and research institutes. Local communities should be included in the process via job creation, infrastructure and revenue sharing mechanism.

From farms to global value chains

Agriculture is another area of under-utilised resources. Pakistan grows rice, mangoes, dates, citrus, meat, dairy, vegetables and seafood but its footprints in international agriculture market is modest. The export of mango fetches significantly less value than it could if graded, packaged, branded and marketed internationally. The same is true for rice, meat, fruits, dairy and fisheries.

We needs to think of agriculture as an agri-business value chain. Cold storages, advanced warehousing, food processing, packaging, certification, digital marketplace and improved logistics can add a lot of value.

There is a need also for improved water productivity. We cannot afford to stick to traditional practices. Advanced agriculture technology - including precision agriculture, advanced irrigation systems, drought-resistant seeds and digital technology - should be adopted to transform agriculture.

Beyond the coastline

Pakistan’s coastline is yet another largely under explored asset. The blue economy goes way beyond fisheries. There are aquaculture, fish processing, shipbuilding, maritime transport and tourism. Karachi, Port Qasim and Gawadar should not be seen as mere transit points through which cargo travels in and out of the country.

A modernised seafood industry can connect fishermen with cold storages, processing units, labs for certification and international markets. Aquaculture can provide employment and export opportunities. Coastal tourism can bring money onto coastal communities and support hotel services, transport and local businesses.

A blue economy policy needs to concentrate on value addition, technological innovation, environmental sustainability and private investments rather than increasing volume of fishing or port activities.

The digital economy

Perhaps Pakistan’s greatest economic resource is its young population. The IT sector has demonstrated potential. The production of software, freelancing, business process outsourcing, fin-tech, artificial intelligence and cyber security services could bring in foreign investment without requiring traditional infrastructure.

The next step must be to produce globally competitive technological products. University-industry collaboration must be enhanced. Technical education needs to keep pace with the market. Artificial intelligence should be considered not just a technology for better governance but also as a new industrial sector.

Geography as an asset

Location alone cannot make a nation prosperous. Efficient logistics, modern custom facilities, rail links, warehouse and logistics parks, efficient document handling and consistent cross border trade transactions are needed for converting geography into an economic resource.

The country’s proximity to Central Asia, China, the Middle East and South Asia allows it to become a regional trade and logistics hub. Exporting goods manufactured in Pakistan is not the only way of benefiting from the location. Pakistan can also transport, store, process and distribute goods from neighbouring and regional economies.

Tourism

Tourism is a much talked about yet a largely untapped opportunity. The mountains in Gilgit-Baltistan and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa; historic cities in the Punjab and Sindh; archeological sites, religious monuments, deserts and coastal areas can be tapped to develop adventure tourism, heritage tourism, religious tourism, eco-tourism and medical tourism.

Having natural resources is not enough to foster tourism. Infrastructure, security and management - including accommodation, sanitation, trained guides and digital booking systems - are needed to help visitors travel comfortably.

Developing well-designed tourism clusters can help distribute economic activities beyond major cities, creating jobs for local communities and supporting regional businesses.

From potential to

prosperity

Identifying opportunities is relatively easy; converting them into economic growth is harder. Pakistan needs a practical framework for moving from potential to achievement.

First, priorities

The governments should develop a national economic opportunity map identifying sectors according to their export potential, employment impact, investment requirements, regional benefits and technological potential. Not every opportunity needs to be pursued immediately. Attention should be focused only on opportunities where Pakistan has a competitive advantage.

Second, projects

Economic opportunity does not mean an investment opportunity. A mineral resource, tourism hub or logistics network requires a feasibility study, infrastructure planning, environmental evaluation, financial assessment and implementation strategy to attract serious private investors.

Third, ecosystems

A mine needs roads, water, electricity, processing facilities and skilled manpower. Agriculture needs packaging, cold storage, quality certifications and logistics. IT needs broadband connectivity, skills, data infrastructure, finance and access to international markets. Pakistan should design clusters where investments reinforce economic activity.

Fourth, investment

environment

Predictability is far more important for investors than any special incentives. Frequent changes in investment rules, import regulation, energy prices and taxation increase uncertainty for long term decisions. Pakistan needs a stable, transparent and predictable investment environment. The objective should be to compete for investments based on productivity and competitiveness rather than through endless incentives.

Fifth, human development

Pakistan cannot develop a modern mining industry without mining engineers, its digital economy without IT professionals and its advanced agri-businesses without food scientists and logistics professionals. There is an obvious need for better integration between universities, technical colleges and vocational training programs with the economic needs. There is a need for skills policy to follow the economic policy.

Sixth, measurement

Economic policy must not be judged on how many projects have been launched or how much money has been invested. The questions that matters include: How much private investment was generated? How many productive jobs were created? How much local value addition took place? How much foreign exchange was earned? How much productivity increased?

From stabilisation to

transformation

Pakistan has become accustomed to thinking in terms of the next budget, the next IMF programme and the next balance of payments crisis. Stabilisation is important, but it cannot be the destination. The real objective should be transformation.

Pakistan’s exports, for example, need to become more diversified and sophisticated. Its agriculture needs greater value addition. Its mineral resources need to support industrialisation. Its young population needs to become a global services export. Its geography needs to support regional trade. Its coastline needs to become the foundation of a maritime economy.

None of this can happen through a single government initiative. It requires policy continuity, institutional capacity, private investment, skilled people and a willingness to stay the course beyond political and budgetary cycles.

Pakistan does not necessarily need to discover another source of wealth; great wealth lies beneath the surface, in the fields, at the coast, in the mountains and in the urban centres of Pakistan. The challenge is to connect these assets with capital, technology, infrastructure and markets. That is the real meaning of unlocking Pakistan’s economic potential.

A country’s future is not defined merely by how successfully it manages scarcity. It is also defined by how effectively it converts its resources into investment, exports, productive employment and sustainable wealth.


The writer, an independent consultant on sustainable development, economic growth and public infrastructure policy, can be reached via info @watproconsultants.com

Unlocking economic potential