Halting hate speech in its tracks

August 30, 2026

Freedom of speech must not be curtailed on account of criticism

Halting hate speech in its tracks


T

here is no universally accepted definition of hate speech despite familiar experiences of those who have suffered on account of it. The experience cannot be comprehensively reported.

The hate informing intolerant actions may be a result of indoctrinated intention. An expression of hate can have many consequences. It reflects a system premised on learning and teaching of it, both through implicit and explicit messaging - in mass media, including school literature, and the cyberspaces where only dominant narratives are permitted.

To legislate on it effectively is a matter of immense importance since hate speech has an emotional sense attached to a person. It is important to understand the person or institution legislating or formulating policy actions and how they define hate speech.

Pakistan signed the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in 2008 and ratified it in 2010. Its obligations are now binding under international law. Pakistan is also under compliance of EU GSP+, which also monitors Pakistan’s performance. Two clauses in the ICCPR are particular importance in this context: Articles 19 and 20, which concern freedom of expression and the prohibition of advocacy of hatred that amounts to incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence.

In 2012, the Rabat Plan of Action, developed through a multi-state expert process, provided an expert tool to help devise laws on limiting expression. This provided for a framework to determine restrictions on freedom of expression when six-part threshold points are crossed. Its six-part threshold considers the context, the position and status of the speaker, intent, the content and form of the expression, its extent or reach and the likelihood and imminence of harm.

The framework provided for an understanding that only if an expression crosses the six threshold, should a state place restrictions on it. Our lawmakers should comprehend the essence of the framework in place. This is an important consideration because several individuals have been charged with cybercrimes because the law apparently conflates criticism and opposition with hate speech. Some well-known human rights defenders have, as a result, been incarcerated over tweets that are claimed to have attracted certain provisions of the PECA.

The Rabat Plan of Action has inferred the meaning of hate speech under the working definition provided by the United Nations Strategy and Plan of Action on Hate Speech as: “any kind of communication in speech, writing or behaviour, that attacks or uses pejorative or discriminatory language with reference to a person or a group on the basis of who they are, in other words, based on their religion, ethnicity, nationality, race, colour, descent, gender or other identity factor.”

Pakistan signed the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in 2008 and ratified it in 2010. Articles 19 and 20 concern freedom of expression and the prohibition of advocacy of hatred that amounts to incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs ensured Pakistan’s participation in the deliberations leading to the Rabat Plan of Action on behalf of the OIC Coordination. In a statement delivered by Counsellor Muneeb Ahmed in Geneva in September 2024, Pakistan highlighted the need to balance freedom of expression with freedom of religion or belief in online spaces. He stressed the importance of asking “who is harmed, and how can we protect them?” He commended the Rabat Plan’s victim-oriented approach. He also said, “We must continue our dialogue on how to apply the RPOA and similar tools in a digital age. The authenticity of information, speed of dissemination and algorithmic manipulation, all impact human rights in profound ways; although social media also empowers individuals in ways that are not always adverse.”

Hate speech, in simple terms, means deliberate insult or intimidation by those in power and insecure on account of the presence of others in their power-sharing intent. The dominant is not always the one in numerical majority. They may also be a minority with immense power.

Pakistan may not yet have a uniform policy or comprehensive framework for addressing hate speech. There have, however, been important judicial and policy interventions.

The 2014 Jillani Judgment, for example, directed that appropriate curricula be developed at school and college levels to promote religious and social tolerance and called for measures protecting the rights of religious minorities.

The National Counter Extremism Policy Guidelines 2018, developed by the NACTA, similarly identified intolerance, self-righteousness and polarisation into ‘us vs them’ as factors that can lead to violence. The guidelines proposed interventions relating to rule of law; citizen and media engagement; institutional reforms; rehabilitation and reintegration; and the promotion of a culture of tolerance.

This important policy framework has yet to receive meaningful uptake by education departments and authorities.

There are legislative gaps in how the state is approaching hate speech. Historically, there have been laws covering provocation of religious sentiments, public order offences, national security and terrorism. The new lens is cyber regulation. The issue has been barely addressed from a human rights lens. Blurring the distinction in terms of “anti-state criticism” and conflating it with “hate speech” is problematic.

Political dissent should not attract censorship. To earn the goodwill and confidence of its citizens, state authorities must encourage fact-based opinions and constructive criticism. Freedom of speech must not be curtailed simply on account of opposition and criticism.

There is a need also to improve media and news literacy, which should be disseminated both as a skill and a social attribute.


The writer is an education rights advocate based in Islamabad. She can be reached at [email protected]

Halting hate speech in its tracks