The Sindh High Court has directed a private school to halt its operations in a residential area within six months if the conversion of the building is not approved by the competent authority under the building regulations.
The order came on petitions concerning the operation of a private school in a residential area of Gulshan-e-Iqbal, Karachi. The private school submitted that it was being operated in a residential area within the statutory framework.
The court was informed that the school was being operated in an area that could only be classified as mixed-use, as both residential and commercial establishments were present in the area.
The counsel said that the operation of the school could not be regarded as commercial use of the premises and that the counter-petition had been filed only for the purpose of extortion, as several other educational establishments were operating in the area. He said that the respondent neighbour had challenged only the operation of the petitioner’s school.
The neighbour of the private school challenged the operation of commercial activities in a residential area, arguing that they could not be permitted, and sought a direction to the school administration to shift the school to a commercial space.
The respondent’s counsel argued that the operation of the school was barred under the Karachi Building and Town Planning Regulations. They said that the premises had not been converted for commercial use and that even if the school applied for conversion, the same would not be permissible under the parameters defined under the Constitution.
The Sindh Building Control Authority also supported the respondents’ arguments and requested the court to dismiss the school’s petition. The SHC’s division bench, comprising Justice Adnan-ul-Karim Memon and Justice Mohammad Jaffer Raza, after hearing the arguments of the counsel, observed that, on perusal of the relevant provisions of the regulations, residential plots within residential neighbourhoods could be used for educational purposes, subject to the approval of certain conditions under the regulations.
The court observed that the petitioner school had not applied for such conversion; therefore, its case was not covered under that provision. The court directed the school to halt its operations on the subject premises within six months to ensure that alternative arrangements were made and the educational activities of the students were not disrupted.
The court observed that the petitioner was at liberty to seek the necessary approval identified in the regulations and could operate the school beyond the six-month period only if such approval was granted by the competent authority.
The court also observed that, if the petitioner school applied for conversion, the competent authority was directed to process the application expeditiously, strictly in accordance with the law and the parameters defined by the Federal Constitutional Court.