close

The case for a child registry

A representational image of a nurse preparing a vaccine to be administered to a patient. — AFP/File
A representational image of a nurse preparing a vaccine to be administered to a patient. — AFP/File

Consider a girl born in a village in Tharparkar. Her father registers her birth at the union council, so on paper she exists. The vaccinator never finds her house and she misses her measles shot.

By her second birthday, she is too short for her age, and the damage to her developing brain will be hard to undo. At seven, she has still not set foot in a classroom, and no government office has noticed any of it. Pakistan has millions of children like her.

About 40 per cent of Pakistani children under five are stunted, roughly 12 million according to the 2018 National Nutrition Survey. Pakistan is one of only two countries where poliovirus still circulates, and it belongs to a small group of countries that together account for more than half of the world’s children who have never had a single routine vaccine. Unicef estimates that 25.1 million children between 5 and 16 are out of school, the second highest number in the world. Among those who do attend, a nationwide learning survey found that only about half of grade five students could read a simple story written for grade two. Sahil, a child protection organisation, recorded more than nine cases of child abuse a day in 2025, and it counts only the cases that reached the system.

Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal told an international conference on nutrition in September that spending on nutrition is economic policy, not charity. He is right. The same argument holds for vaccines and schools, and in each case the policy can only reach children the state knows how to find.

Stunting, missed vaccines, empty classrooms and unreported abuse look like problems for four different departments, but they have a common root. The state cannot serve children it cannot see. This is a state that biometrically verifies every mobile SIM in the country and sends polio teams to chalk every door, yet it has no way of telling whether a registered child ever reached a classroom.

Most public debate on child welfare is about money, usually more schools and more clinics. That case has merit. But it assumes the binding constraint is delivery, when the binding constraint is often information. A vaccination team cannot reach a child it cannot locate, and a school cannot enroll a child nobody has recorded.

Nobel laureate James Heckman has shown that investment in people pays off most in the earliest years of life. A child who is well fed in her first thousand days learns faster and stays in school longer, and as an adult she earns more and raises healthier children. The logic also runs in reverse. Stunting that is not caught early is largely permanent, so each year a child spends outside the system raises the cost of reaching her and lowers the return. Pakistan’s demographic dividend hinges on this. A young population is an economic asset only if it grows up healthy and skilled.

The problem begins at birth. According to the 2017 to 2018 Pakistan Demographic and Health Survey, still the most widely cited national figure, only 42 per cent of children under five had their births registered. NADRA’s own performance report shows that 31.9 million births recorded by union councils have yet to reach its central database, so even a girl whose father did everything right may be invisible to the national system. The gap is closing, if slowly. NADRA reports that registration of children under 18 rose 11 per cent in 2025, and registration drives continue with mobile vans in the field and digital birth registration in Punjab and Sindh.

NADRA already registers about 97 per cent of the population, and its former chairman Tariq Malik was recently named among the world’s 50 leading figures in digital public infrastructure. While the technology is there, what Pakistan still needs is a political decision to finish registering its youngest citizens and to use the registry for their welfare.

BISP offers a working version of the idea. It uses its poverty database to identify the poorest fifth of households, and two of its programmes follow individual children. Benazir Nashonuma pays mothers of children under two when they keep up health visits, including growth checks and vaccinations. Waseela e Taleem pays families when their children attend school. In other words, the state can follow a named child into a clinic or a classroom when it decides to. Both programmes stop at the poorest registered households, though, and they track only what the payment is tied to.

The next step is to extend that logic to every child. Picture it from a mother’s side. When her baby’s next vaccine is due, she gets a text message, and if the dose is missed, the vaccinator is told where to go. If her toddler falls behind on weight, the Lady Health Worker knocks on her door. If her ten-year-old appears on no school register, public or private, someone from the district office calls. For this to work, every record the state keeps on a child, from the union council to the classroom, has to carry the same NADRA number. The Lady Health Worker programme employs close to 90,000 women, though its own strategic plan says they reach only about 40 per cent of the population. That reach needs to grow, and nutrition checks for every child under two should be added to the job.

Abuse is harder to track, but the same approach applies. Schools and Lady Health Workers should be required to report suspected abuse to district child protection officers. A child who drops off both health and school records should get a welfare visit, since vanishing from every register is a warning sign in itself.

Since the 18th Amendment, health, education and child protection have been provincial subjects, so this has to be a provincial project. Some of the pieces are already in place. Sindh’s Zindagi Mehfooz registry records the vaccination history of individual children across the province and sends parents reminders when a dose is due. Punjab and the other provinces run their own health and school information systems. The trouble is that these systems do not talk to each other or to NADRA.

Zindagi Mehfooz, for instance, identifies children by its own QR code rather than their national registration number. Islamabad’s job should be to set a common identifier and data-sharing standards. The provinces can then build the links through the departments and budgets they already have, without creating a new agency.

The obvious objection is that a state that struggles to deliver vaccines today will not do any better with a database. But weak delivery is partly a product of weak information. Today a missed dose leaves no trace in any system, and neither does a child who never enrolls, so no official has to answer for either. A database will not make the state competent by itself. It would make failure visible and attributable – and accountability has to start somewhere.

Pakistan has built the infrastructure of recognition without the infrastructure of care. It gives a child a number and then learns very little about whether she is fed, vaccinated, in school or safe. A registry is only useful when someone is answerable for the child behind each entry, and for most children nobody yet is. The number exists. As far as the state is concerned, the girl in Tharparkar does not.


The writer is an assistant professor of economics and director of the Economic Growth and Forecasting Lab at the Institute of Business Administration (IBA), Karachi.