PESHAWAR: The Peshawar High Court (PHC) on Wednesday dismissed a writ petition challenging the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government’s decision to appoint the chief minister as chairman of the Board of Governors (BoG) of Edwardes College Peshawar, upholding the provincial government’s decision.
The petition was heard by a two-member bench comprising Justice Wiqar Ahmad and Justice Farah Jamshed. Additional Advocate General Waqar Orakzai and counsel for the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Governor appeared before the court.
Counsel for Governor Faisal Karim Kundi told the court that under the law, the governor served as chairman of the BoG of the Edwardes College, Peshawar. He referred to a 1974 legal notification stating that the governor would be the chairman of the college’s BoG.
He said clear judgments of the Supreme Court also existed on the matter. However, the provincial cabinet, in a meeting, had appointed the chief minister as chairman of the BoG under the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Educational and Training Institutes Law of 1971.
The lawyer said Edwardes College, one of the province’s historic educational institutions, was established by the Christian missionary service in 1900 to address the lack of educational facilities. It was later handed over to the provincial government under the Private School Authority in 1972, with the understanding that its affairs would be managed by a BoG headed by the governor.
According to the petition, the provincial cabinet began taking control of the college’s affairs on October 2, after which two separate notifications were issued on October 14 and October 29, 2025. The notifications stated that no permanent principal should be appointed until the provincial government made a decision regarding the college’s affairs.
The petitioner’s counsel maintained that the Supreme Court, in a 2024 judgment, had held that the affairs of Edwardes College would be managed by its BoG and that the governor would serve as its chairman. He argued that the provincial government’s decision amounted to an overreach of its authority.
He further told the court that the ongoing dispute over control of the college had adversely affected the institution. More than 700 students had reportedly failed during the previous year, which he attributed primarily to the power struggle among different groups within the college.
He said several decisions had been issued in the past and attempts had also been made on various occasions to transfer the college’s administrative authority to the provincial government. However, he argued that the 2024 Supreme Court judgment restricted such moves.
According to the petitioner, the provincial government had now taken a fresh step while disregarding the Supreme Court judgment, giving itself authority to decide on the appointment of the college’s permanent principal. He contended that the move was unconstitutional and unlawful.
During the hearing, AAG Waqar Orakzai argued that the provincial government had the authority to legislate and regularly enacted laws concerning various institutions. He said the provincial government provided funding to Edwardes College and that the decision had not been taken by an individual but had been approved by the provincial cabinet.
He maintained that the affairs of Edwardes College had been affected and that the consequences were evident. The provincial cabinet therefore approved new legislation, which the government subsequently enacted in accordance with the cabinet’s decision.
The AAG said the new legislation would have positive effects on the college.After hearing arguments from both sides, the court dismissed the writ petition and upheld the provincial government’s decision.