When I started writing for the op-ed section of The News International in November 1993, Dr Maleeha Lodhi was the editor of the Rawalpindi edition of that paper, and the editorial pages of The News at that time were managed by her. She readily agreed to publish my columns, primarily on international affair. This association with The News continues to this day.
In the last 35 years, The News International has played a leading role in journalism, and its columns are read far and wide, having an impact on the policy-making process. Although academia remained my profession, writing a weekly column in newspapers such as Morning News, The Muslim, The News and the Daily Times enabled me to emerge also as a columnist.
The culture of the column has three major facets. First, it is opinion-oriented, which helps the readers to understand the dynamics of critical issues. Second, columns may reflect the analytical skills and critical thinking of writers. Third, columns may have an impact on policies because, within a range of 1,000 to 1,200 words, a column, by following precision, tries to give a message to readers.
Columns also help in educating readers about various issues and help sharpen analytical skills and critical thinking. A columnist can act as a catalyst for bringing qualitative change in society. But that is only possible when there is freedom of expression and the columnist communicates his/her message without any fear or coercion.
By the time I emerged as a professional and prolific columnist, I had managed to create a constituency of readers who looked forward to my writings. While my focus was on international and national affairs, the challenge of a grip over facts and substance covering analytical skills remained in place. Keeping oneself up to date and having command over current affairs with adequate knowledge about historical events also posed a challenge for a good columnist. As a columnist, I was mindful of the adequate usage of words, vocabulary and precision in expression.
As a non-conformist columnist with objective thinking, I faced numerous challenges. For instance, I wrote a column for the op-ed section of The News International entitled "Political Change or Status Quo?”, published on 4 September 1996, which depicted the pros and cons of the political crisis engulfing the country between the government of Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto and the Opposition. Based on an objective analysis of the political situation which prevailed at that time, I proposed three options to manage the political crisis: quiet revolution, violent revolution and benign dictatorship. In the end, I suggested that despite polarisation at the national level, the political process should continue and no unconstitutional measures to destabilise the government should be taken.
On 9 September 1996, five days after the publication of the column, I was shocked when I received a letter from the Registrar and then Vice-Chancellor of the University of Karachi suspending me from service and banning my entry into the premises of the university. The charges, which were later mentioned in the show cause notice dated 10 September 1996, stated that in my above mentioned column I had "propagated dictatorship and conspired to overthrow the government. The publication of that column became an issue to the extent that several quarters criticised the decision of the government, as the orders to suspend me came from the top. I responded to the show cause notice through my lawyer, denying the charges and demanding the withdrawal of the suspension order and the ban on my entry into my university. Several columnists and civil society activists supported my stance. My column became the source of a movement which was launched by university teachers and human rights organisations, to the extent that on 30 September 1996 the suspension order and ban on entering the premises of my university were withdrawn. In the first week of October, in an editorial published in The News International, while welcoming the government's decision to withdraw my suspension, it lamented that academic freedom had been violated by the university authorities and the government.
The lessons learned from my column of 4 September 1996 and the subsequent action against me galvanised a movement for academic freedom. It gave me moral strength and courage to remain bold and courageous in my columns.
As days are passing, ethics, morality and professionalism are dwindling among many columnists. A lack of innovation and creativity is common, and this has to do with the mitigation of a culture of reading. When the country's educational system is at risk and the pursuit of knowledge is not the goal, the outcome is the emergence of mediocre and below-mediocre culture of writing columns.
Unfortunately, along with the erosion of the culture of reading, there is also a decline in the reading of newspapers. I was shocked when my hawker told me a while ago that at the University of Karachi, during weekdays, he delivers only 70 newspapers, including in departments, offices and houses on campus. At the weekend, the number of newspaper deliveries increases to 90 only. There is no substitute for reading a hard copy of a newspaper instead of relying on an online version. But when there is a serious decline in the reading of hard copies of newspapers and magazines, columnists do not feel any compulsion to write at first hand.
Restoring the culture of the column is an uphill task and would require commitment, dedication, and command over expression, subject, originality, creativity, innovation and courage. Since there is a decline in the standard of columns, editors of newspapers must make sure that they do not compromise on principles. Imposing curbs on the freedom of expression will dilute the purpose of writing columns.
—The writer is Meritorious Professor of International Relations and former Dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Karachi. He can be reached at: [email protected]